[Intermediate] — What “approaches” means precisely enough to build on, and why the value at a point is irrelevant to the limit near it.

Before you start

What you will be able to do after this lesson:

  1. State informally what means.
  2. Explain why the limit does not depend on , and give an example where they differ.
  3. Evaluate limits by substitution, by factoring, and by rationalising.
  4. Identify one-sided limits and say when a two-sided limit fails to exist.

1. The definition, informally

means: as gets arbitrarily close to , gets arbitrarily close to .

Note what it does not say. It says nothing about . The limit is about the neighbourhood of , deliberately excluding itself.

That exclusion is not a technicality — it is the entire point. The tangent problem needs the value that approaches as , and that expression is undefined at . If limits required the function to be defined at the point, calculus would not exist.

2. A function whose limit and value disagree

At this is — undefined. The function has a hole there.

But near , factor the numerator:

0.90.990.99911.0011.011.1
1.91.991.999undefined2.0012.012.1

The limit is 2, even though does not exist. The function approaches 2 from both sides; whether it arrives is a separate question.

NOTE

The cancellation is legal precisely because of the exclusion. Dividing by requires — and the limit never evaluates at , so the requirement is always satisfied.

This is the standard technique: an indeterminate usually means a common factor is hiding. Cancel it and the limit becomes a substitution.

3. How to actually evaluate a limit

Try substitution first. If is defined and the function has no jump there, the limit is . Most limits are this easy.

If you get , that is not the answer — it is a signal. It means the expression is hiding a removable factor. Three standard moves:

Factor and cancel:

Rationalise, when a square root is involved:

Simplify a compound fraction:

4. One-sided limits, and when the limit fails

Approaching from the left and from the right can give different answers:

The two-sided limit exists only if both one-sided limits exist and are equal.

For : approaching 0 from the right gives ; from the left, . They disagree, so does not exist — even though both one-sided limits do.

Three ways a limit fails to exist:

  1. A jump — the one-sided limits disagree, as above.
  2. Unbounded growth — grows without bound. Writing describes how it fails; it is not a value.
  3. Oscillation — oscillates infinitely fast and settles on nothing.

5. Practice — problems

  1. Evaluate by substitution: (a) (b) .
  2. Evaluate by factoring: (a) (b) .
  3. Evaluate by rationalising: .
  4. For , find , , and .
  5. Explain in one sentence why can exist when does not, and why calculus needs that to be true.
  6. Evaluate . You have just computed a derivative — of what function, at what point?
Answers — open only after an attempt
  1. (a) . (b) .
  2. (a) . (b) .
  3. Multiply by : numerator becomes , giving .
  4. Left limit ; right limit ; so the two-sided limit is 3. But . The limit and the value disagree — the function is defined at 2, just not at the value it approaches. This is a removable discontinuity.
  5. The limit describes the behaviour of near , deliberately excluding itself — and calculus needs that because the difference quotient is always undefined at , so a definition requiring the value there would define nothing.
  6. . That is the derivative of at — and at is indeed 6.

Before moving on

  • State informally what a limit is.
  • Explain why the limit ignores the value at the point, and why that matters.
  • Evaluate a limit by factoring and by rationalising.
  • Say when a two-sided limit fails to exist, and name three ways it can.

Recap: means gets arbitrarily close to as gets arbitrarily close to — with deliberately excluded. That exclusion is what lets calculus define a derivative, since the difference quotient is undefined at the point itself. Substitution works when the function is well behaved; signals a hidden common factor to cancel or rationalise. A two-sided limit exists only when both one-sided limits agree.

Next: Limit Laws — the rules that let you evaluate limits without a table of values every time.

↑ Back to Mathematics