[Advanced] — The four balance principles, one derivation pattern used four times, and why the resulting system is deliberately underdetermined.
The pattern
Every balance law here has the same shape:
rate of change of X inside a region = flux of X across its boundary + production of X inside
And every one is derived the same way:
- Write the statement as integrals over an arbitrary material volume
- Convert surface integrals to volume integrals with the divergence theorem
- Collect everything under one integral
- Argue that since the volume is arbitrary, the integrand must vanish pointwise
Step 4 is the move that converts a global statement into a PDE. Learn the pattern once and all four derivations are the same exercise. → Index Notation
Two tools recur:
The divergence theorem:
Reynolds transport theorem — how to differentiate an integral over a moving material volume:
That’s the material derivative from note 03, applied to an integral. It’s the bridge between “follow the material” and “watch a fixed region”.
1. Conservation of mass
Mass is neither created nor destroyed.
Apply the pattern:
The continuity equation. Equivalently .
Incompressible flow means , which forces
A divergence-free velocity field. This is a constraint, not an evolution equation — nothing tells you how it evolves, it must simply hold at every instant. That’s what makes incompressible Navier–Stokes awkward to solve numerically: pressure becomes a Lagrange multiplier enforcing the constraint rather than a thermodynamic variable, and you get a saddle-point problem. → Navier–Stokes
In Lagrangian (solid) form, mass conservation is simply
reference density equals Jacobian times current density. Cleaner, and it’s one reason solid mechanics prefers the material description.
2. Balance of linear momentum
Newton’s second law for a continuum. Forces come in two kinds:
- Body forces — gravity, electromagnetic, acting throughout the volume
- Surface tractions — contact forces on the boundary
Apply the pattern:
Cauchy’s equation of motion, and the single most important equation in the field.
Everything specialises from it:
| Set | Get |
|---|---|
| static equilibrium — most of solid mechanics | |
| = Newtonian fluid | Navier–Stokes |
| = Hooke’s law | Navier’s equations of elastodynamics |
| Euler’s equations — inviscid flow |
One equation, every material. The balance law is universal; what changes is the constitutive model you substitute for . That’s the structural point of note 01 made concrete.
Expanding the material derivative gives the nonlinear convective term:
That is why fluid dynamics is hard.
3. Balance of angular momentum
Moments balance too. Running the same derivation on and subtracting the linear-momentum result leaves:
Angular momentum balance is exactly the statement that the stress tensor is symmetric. It contributes no new differential equation — it constrains the stress tensor instead, cutting nine components to six.
That’s a genuinely elegant result: a conservation law that shows up as an algebraic symmetry rather than a PDE. → Stress
(In micropolar continua with distributed couples it does give an extra equation and is non-symmetric — relevant to granular media, out of scope here.)
4. Conservation of energy
The first law of thermodynamics for a continuum:
where is internal energy per unit mass, the heat flux, a heat source, and the rate of deformation.
The term is the stress power — the rate at which mechanical work converts to internal energy. It’s the reason:
- Repeatedly bending a paperclip heats it — plastic work becomes heat
- Viscous fluids dissipate energy and warm up
- High-speed metal forming needs thermal coupling in the simulation
- Damping in a vibrating structure is energy leaving mechanically and arriving thermally
Where energy balance matters: thermo-mechanical coupling (thermal stress, forming, welding), compressible flow (where pressure, density and temperature are linked), and anything where dissipation is significant.
Where it doesn’t: isothermal small-strain elasticity — which is most of undergraduate solid mechanics, and why the energy equation often goes unmentioned.
The second law
The Clausius–Duhem inequality — entropy production is non-negative:
This is not a balance law you solve. It’s a restriction on admissible constitutive models.
Any material law you propose must satisfy it for every conceivable deformation, and that’s a genuinely strong filter:
- Viscosity must be positive — a “material” with negative viscosity would create energy
- Thermal conductivity must be positive — heat cannot spontaneously flow up a gradient
- Elastic moduli must be positive definite
- Hyperelastic materials must derive stress from a stored energy potential — which is what makes them path-independent and non-dissipative
The Coleman–Noll procedure is the systematic way to extract these restrictions, and it’s why constitutive modelling is a discipline rather than curve-fitting. → Constitutive Models
Counting: why the system is underdetermined
The crucial bookkeeping.
Unknowns (isothermal, 3D):
| count | |
|---|---|
| density | 1 |
| velocity | 3 |
| stress (symmetric) | 6 |
| total | 10 |
Equations:
| count | |
|---|---|
| mass | 1 |
| linear momentum | 3 |
| angular momentum | 0 (used up as symmetry) |
| total | 4 |
Six equations short.
The balance laws are universal and therefore incomplete. They apply equally to steel and water precisely because they say nothing about what the material is. The missing six equations are the constitutive model, and they are material-specific, empirical, and where every modelling decision lives.
That deficit is not a flaw in the theory — it’s the theory correctly separating what is certain (conservation) from what is chosen (material response).
Adding temperature adds one unknown () and one equation (energy), plus a constitutive law for heat flux (Fourier’s law) — the same structure repeats.
Boundary and initial conditions
A PDE system needs them, and the classification matters:
Dirichlet (essential) — prescribed displacement or velocity on part of the boundary. A fixed support.
Neumann (natural) — prescribed traction. An applied pressure, or a free surface where .
Mixed / Robin — a relation between them. An elastic foundation, or convective heat transfer.
Every point of the boundary needs exactly one condition per direction — you cannot prescribe both displacement and traction in the same direction at the same point, and you must not leave a direction unspecified. Under-constraining is the classic FE error: a model with a rigid-body mode has a singular stiffness matrix, and the solver reports it as “insufficient boundary conditions” or simply fails to converge.
The “essential/natural” naming comes from the variational formulation, where essential conditions must be built into the trial space while natural ones fall out of the weak form automatically. → FEM
Related
- Stress — what the momentum balance is written in
- Constitutive Models — the six missing equations
- Navier–Stokes — the fluid specialisation
- Continuum mechanics map
Software engineering
Infrastructure & security
Computer science
Hardware & engineering